This page (revision-5) was last changed on 2025-05-06 02:06 by Murray Altheim

This page was created on 2019-12-21 22:13 by unknown

Only authorized users are allowed to rename pages.

Only authorized users are allowed to delete pages.

Page revision history

Version Date Modified Size Author Changes ... Change note
5 2025-05-06 02:06 10 KB Murray Altheim to previous
4 2025-05-06 02:04 10 KB Murray Altheim to previous | to last
3 2025-05-06 02:03 10 KB Murray Altheim to previous | to last
2 2025-05-06 01:57 10 KB Murray Altheim to previous | to last
1 2019-12-21 22:13 278 bytes unknown to last

Page References

Incoming links Outgoing links
Robot Control Systems
RobotControlSystems

Version management

Difference between version and

At line 22 changed one line
* Deliberative control systems follow a structured “sense-plan-act” approach, where the robot first gathers sensor data, builds an internal model of the environment, and then uses that model to generate a plan before executing any actions. This architecture excels in predictable, well-structured environments and is well-suited for complex tasks that require strategic decision-making, such as path planning or task scheduling. However, its reliance on accurate models and heavy computation makes it less responsive to rapidly changing conditions or environments with high uncertainty.
** __Deliberative control__ systems follow a structured “sense-plan-act” approach, where the robot first gathers sensor data, builds an internal model of the environment, and then uses that model to generate a plan before executing any actions. This architecture excels in predictable, well-structured environments and is well-suited for complex tasks that require strategic decision-making, such as path planning or task scheduling. However, its reliance on accurate models and heavy computation makes it less responsive to rapidly changing conditions or environments with high uncertainty.
At line 24 changed 2 lines
* Uses detailed models of the world.
* Performs long-term planning before acting.
** Uses detailed models of the world.
** Performs long-term planning before acting.
At line 27 changed 2 lines
* Capable of sophisticated reasoning.
* Good for tasks requiring long-term planning.
** Capable of sophisticated reasoning.
** Good for tasks requiring long-term planning.
At line 30 changed 2 lines
* Computationally intensive.
* Not suitable for dynamic or unpredictable environments.
** Computationally intensive.
** Not suitable for dynamic or unpredictable environments.
At line 37 changed one line
* Reactive control bypasses complex modeling and long-term planning by responding directly to sensory inputs with predefined behaviors or control rules. These systems are designed for speed and robustness, especially in dynamic or uncertain environments, where quick decisions are critical. Instead of maintaining an internal map, a reactive robot might immediately turn away from obstacles or follow light sources based solely on current sensor readings. While fast and simple, reactive systems can struggle with tasks that require coordination over time or consideration of distant goals.
** __Reactive control__ bypasses complex modeling and long-term planning by responding directly to sensory inputs with predefined behaviors or control rules. These systems are designed for speed and robustness, especially in dynamic or uncertain environments, where quick decisions are critical. Instead of maintaining an internal map, a reactive robot might immediately turn away from obstacles or follow light sources based solely on current sensor readings. While fast and simple, reactive systems can struggle with tasks that require coordination over time or consideration of distant goals.
At line 39 changed 2 lines
* Ignores internal models and global planning.
* Based on behaviors triggered by environmental stimuli.
** Ignores internal models and global planning.
** Based on behaviors triggered by environmental stimuli.
At line 42 changed 2 lines
* Fast response times.
* Robust in dynamic environments.
** Fast response times.
** Robust in dynamic environments.
At line 45 changed 2 lines
* Limited long-term planning.
* Can struggle with complex tasks.
** Limited long-term planning.
** Can struggle with complex tasks.
At line 52 changed one line
* Hybrid control systems aim to combine the strengths of both deliberative and reactive approaches by layering a high-level planner over low-level reactive behaviors. The planning layer is responsible for setting goals and generating overall strategies, while the reactive layer handles immediate responses to the environment. This architecture allows for strategic decision-making without sacrificing responsiveness to new or unexpected stimuli. Despite its power and flexibility, designing an effective hybrid system can be complex due to challenges in coordinating the interactions between layers.
** __Hybrid control__ systems aim to combine the strengths of both deliberative and reactive approaches by layering a high-level planner over low-level reactive behaviors. The planning layer is responsible for setting goals and generating overall strategies, while the reactive layer handles immediate responses to the environment. This architecture allows for strategic decision-making without sacrificing responsiveness to new or unexpected stimuli. Despite its power and flexibility, designing an effective hybrid system can be complex due to challenges in coordinating the interactions between layers.
At line 54 changed one line
* Typically includes a high-level planner and low-level reactive behaviors.
** Typically includes a high-level planner and low-level reactive behaviors.
At line 56 changed 2 lines
* Balances planning and responsiveness.
* Versatile across various tasks and environments.
** Balances planning and responsiveness.
** Versatile across various tasks and environments.
At line 59 changed one line
* Can be complex to design and integrate.
** Can be complex to design and integrate.
At line 65 changed one line
* Behavior-based control organizes robot intelligence as a collection of independent behaviors, each responsible for a specific function like obstacle avoidance, goal-seeking, or wall-following. These behaviors run in parallel, and a behavior arbitration mechanism determines which one controls the robot at any moment. The architecture emphasizes modularity and robustness, enabling robots to exhibit complex, adaptive behavior through simple interactions. However, because behaviors can interact in unpredictable ways, designing and tuning a behavior-based system often requires extensive testing and empirical refinement.
** __Behavior-based control__ organizes robot intelligence as a collection of independent behaviors, each responsible for a specific function like obstacle avoidance, goal-seeking, or wall-following. These behaviors run in parallel, and a behavior arbitration mechanism determines which one controls the robot at any moment. The architecture emphasizes modularity and robustness, enabling robots to exhibit complex, adaptive behavior through simple interactions. However, because behaviors can interact in unpredictable ways, designing and tuning a behavior-based system often requires extensive testing and empirical refinement. See also: [BehaviourBasedSystems]
At line 67 changed one line
* Each behavior handles a specific task (e.g., follow wall, avoid obstacle).
** Each behavior handles a specific task (e.g., follow wall, avoid obstacle).
At line 69 changed 2 lines
* Modular and robust.
* Adaptable to changing conditions.
** Modular and robust.
** Adaptable to changing conditions.
At line 72 changed 2 lines
* Behavior coordination can be tricky.
* Emergent behavior is hard to predict.
** Behavior coordination can be tricky.
** Emergent behavior is hard to predict.
At line 79 changed one line
* Learning-based control relies on data-driven methods—such as supervised learning, unsupervised learning, or reinforcement learning — to develop control policies that map sensory input to actions. These systems are particularly useful in environments that are too complex or poorly understood to model explicitly. By training on real or simulated data, learning-based robots can develop skills like object recognition, navigation, or manipulation. While offering adaptability and generalization, these systems often require significant amounts of data, and their decision-making processes may lack transparency, raising concerns about safety and interpretability.
** __Learning-based control__ relies on data-driven methods—such as supervised learning, unsupervised learning, or reinforcement learning — to develop control policies that map sensory input to actions. These systems are particularly useful in environments that are too complex or poorly understood to model explicitly. By training on real or simulated data, learning-based robots can develop skills like object recognition, navigation, or manipulation. While offering adaptability and generalization, these systems often require significant amounts of data, and their decision-making processes may lack transparency, raising concerns about safety and interpretability.
At line 81 changed one line
* Can be supervised, unsupervised, or reinforcement learning.
** Can be supervised, unsupervised, or reinforcement learning.
At line 83 changed 2 lines
* Capable of adapting to unknown or complex environments.
* Improves with experience.
** Capable of adapting to unknown or complex environments.
** Improves with experience.
At line 86 changed 2 lines
* Requires large datasets or training time.
* Often lacks interpretability and safety guarantees.
** Requires large datasets or training time.
** Often lacks interpretability and safety guarantees.
At line 93 changed one line
* Model Predictive Control (MPC) involves solving an optimization problem at each control step to determine the best sequence of actions over a finite future horizon, based on a predictive model of the system’s dynamics. By continuously updating this plan as new sensor data arrives, MPC allows for precise control that can handle system constraints and anticipate future events. This makes it ideal for tasks like trajectory tracking or collision avoidance in autonomous vehicles. However, the computational load of real-time optimization can limit its use in systems with tight timing constraints or limited processing power.
** __Model Predictive Control__ (MPC) involves solving an optimization problem at each control step to determine the best sequence of actions over a finite future horizon, based on a predictive model of the system’s dynamics. By continuously updating this plan as new sensor data arrives, MPC allows for precise control that can handle system constraints and anticipate future events. This makes it ideal for tasks like trajectory tracking or collision avoidance in autonomous vehicles. However, the computational load of real-time optimization can limit its use in systems with tight timing constraints or limited processing power.
At line 95 changed one line
* Uses a dynamic model to predict future states.
** Uses a dynamic model to predict future states.
At line 97 changed 2 lines
* Precise and optimal over short horizons.
* Handles constraints well.
** Precise and optimal over short horizons.
** Handles constraints well.
At line 100 changed one line
* Computationally demanding in real time.
** Computationally demanding in real time.
This page (revision-5) was last changed on 2025-05-06 02:06 by Murray AltheimTop