Power Supplies
Back to current versionRestore this version

Aliased from USB Power Supplies, WallSupplies, Power Supply, Power Supply Unit and PSU

When you're working on your robot you'll likely want to plug it into a wall socket rather than run it from batteries. You'd call that a Bench Power Supply.

We'll focus on the Raspberry Pi since it generally requires more power than other microcomputers/microcontrollers. Most processors suitable for small robots require either 5 volts or 3.3 volts, but if they have a USB connector on them it's likely so you can use a USB charger as a power supply. Obviously, read the user manual.

The Raspberry Pi requires a 5 volt power supply and generates an onboard regulated 3.3 volt supply for its peripherals. You can use a reliable USB Power Supply (5 volts) with enough current capacity to run your processor (e.g., Raspberry Pi), your sensors, motors and any other accessories (such as displays).

Note: we'll cover battery packs elsewhere.

So How Much Power?#

Serious Power
serious power
There are a number of companies providing USB Power Supplies specifically for the Raspberry Pi. Each of the Raspberry Pi models has different power requirements (see below), with recommended PSU (Power Supply Unit) current capacities ranging from 700mA for the Model A to 3 amps for the Pi 4, but these numbers don't include sensors or motors.

Since you're building a robot, not an alarm clock, at very least a 3 amp supply is probably recommended. With sensors and motors you may need something even bigger. You may need to add up the estimated power consumption of all your components and add a bit extra for safety. Or use a very large power supply and actually measure the power consumption using a multimeter while your robot is running.

Jaycar sell a Mean Well 70W 5V 14A Power Supply that actually delivers 70 watts (5 volts at 14 amps, do the math) for NZ$54.90. It's not as pretty as the Apple unit but as a bench power supply it looks pretty good. Here's the specs:

Rather impressive.

#

Product Recommended PSU Current Maximum USB peripheral draw Typical bare-board consumption
Raspberry Pi Model A+ 700mA 500mA 180mA
Raspberry Pi Zero W 1.2mA Limited by components 150mA
Raspberry Pi 3 Model B+ 2.5A 1.2A 500mA
Raspberry Pi 4 Model B 3.0mA 1.2mA 600mA

The above is a portion of the table from the Raspberry Pi FAQ. There's also a table showing typical power usage "during standard processes" (which doesn't include driving your robot up a steep incline, but might be helpful...). They define a "stressed" Raspberry Pi 3B as using 1.34 amps. Stall current on a robot motor can be 5 amps.

Hmm. Clearly we need to think about this a bit more.

What is a Switching Power Supply?#

My dad used to really like trying to guess what was in his Christmas gifts. I remember one Christmas where as a joke I gave him an extremely heavy transformer from a Bell UH-1 Iroquois helicopter that I'd bought at a local surplus store (I wanted the chassis it was in, or some such reason). I'd put his real gift under the transformer and there were some laughs, ha ha. He then picked up the transformer and dropped it into what he thought was an empty box full of wrapping paper, except it wasn't empty. It contained the Rotal Albert tea cup I'd just given my mom. Ugh.

Some power supplies (what we might call "old school") use a transformer to convert the wall voltage (110 volts in the Canada, the US and Japan, 200-240 volts in most of the rest of the world) down to the low voltage (5-12 volts) used for our robot. The more power we needed, the larger the transformer. The amount of power that could be delivered was almost a direct relation to the size the transformer. Transformers can get big and heavy.

A Switching Power Supply (also called a "switched-mode power supply) doesn't use a big transformer. Most laptop power supplies are switching power supplies. If you're on one of the robot vendor web sites you'll see switching power supplies advertised. AdaFruit sells a 5 volt 10 amp for US$30, another one for $25. Most of these units have the benefit of being able to run from either 110 or 240 volts.

Dishonest Advertising?#

The problem is, the companies selling USB chargers are not always very clear about the power ratings of their products. Apple seems to be the worst: they sell two adapters (listed as the Apple 87W USB-C Power Adapter and the 96W USB-C Power Adapter) that are likely the most expensive on the market and are not showing their output ratings in watts but seemingly their power requirements, i.e, not what they deliver but what they use. Of course it says nothing about this on the box. It's 87 watts, right?

Apple 5 watt USB adapter
Apple 5 watt USB adapter

Apple is really relying on the ignorance of its customers here.

I made the mistake of buying the 87 watt unit for NZ$120 (wow!), opening the box and finding in fine grey print on the adapter a confusing bunch of different amperage ratings at voltages, but at 5 volts the unit delivers 5 volts at 3 amps (i.e., 3000 mA or milliamps). It says this nowhere on the box; I had to unpack the unit and read the 0.8mm light grey text, then return it to the store.

Apple 12 watt USB adapter
Apple 12 watt USB adapter
To give you an idea of how far this is off from that advertised 87 watt promise, delivering 87 watts at 5 volts it should be delivering 17.4 amps. Apple's unit is clearly using 87 watts to deliver 15 watts (3 amps at 5 volts) of power. You can check this yourself by using an online Watts to Amps Calculator or Amps to Watts Calculator.

What's strange is that Apple has delivered honest reporting on its other units. Their tiny 5 watt unit delivers 5 volts at 1 amp. Their 12 watt unit delivers 5.2 volts at 2.4 amps. They provide technical specification for these smaller models, but the "Tech Specs" for the 96 watt model just says "USB C". What gives?

This is where having a bit of your own knowledge is good. These are the two pertinent formulas:

  amps = watts ÷ volts
  watts = amps × volts
If the Raspberry Pi people say your Pi needs 3 amps, that's not how much power the adapter is using (including power wasted through conversion, heat, etc.), it's how much it's required to deliver.

Some of the units I've found say they supply 3 amps but over two separate USB connections, or say they deliver 3.1 amps but have two USB sockets, so is that 3.1 amps for the whole unit or only 1.55 amps per socket? It's hard to tell when vendors aren't honest. I've got a 3SixT USB charger that has this on the bottom:

    Input: AC 100-240V~, 50/60Hz 0.8A Max
    USB 1 Output: 5V = 2.4A Max
    USB 2 Output: 5V = 2.4A Max

Of course, on the box it said it was a "4.8A" unit, but it only delivers 2.4 amps per USB socket, which won't do if I need 3 amps (I use it for the 8" monitor for my Pi). At least it on their packaging and their website this was clear. I've another USB charger that has two sockets and says it delivers 3.1A, but doesn't say if that's for the whole unit or per socket. As it's slightly smaller than the 3SixT adapter I'm guessing the whole unit.

It's a tricky business, and rather difficult to figure out. If your power supply is running hot or your Raspberry Pi resets sometimes due to a brownout (the voltage may dip below 5 volts if the adapter can't supply the necessary amperage), your power supply is probably not big enough.


Tags:  Hardware